Friday, October 9, 2020

Ayurveda, Diabetes, and Mental Health

Ayurveda research really struck a chord of interest in me. This interest actually started when one of my friends began her training in a holistic approach of massage therapy. She had asked me if I would let her practice her new learned techniques on me. I was extremely skeptical as I laid on her table that day while she strategically placed crystals on various parts of my body. The aroma of sage filled the room as she waved it around. She then continued to hover her hands over each crystal and began telling me which muscles were feeling tense and why. I left my session with her feeling a little less skeptical, but there was still some doubt. This past summer I had also met a student who had decided to further her studies in the concept of herbal medicine. It intrigued me as she pointed out various plants and shared that each one of them have a different healing property. 

With Ayurveda it has been accounted for, in classical Ayurveda text, that the Gods had passed down medical knowledge to the sages, which then in turn went from human knowledge to the physicians. When I read this, it reminded me of the student from this summer and I couldn’t help but wonder if maybe she was right, and maybe the plants really did have healing properties. I came across an article that had mentioned all the harmful things to humans that have been found in many Ayurveda medicines and became skeptical once again. How could putting harmful things into your body be beneficial and healing in any way? Simply put, it isn’t. 

I do think the environment has an impact on health in some way. Even physicians will tell you that diet, exercise, and even stress management are extremely important to personal health. All of those things depend on the environment in one way or another. As for connection between parts of the body, I think there is absolutely a connection. If we just listen to our bodies they tell us exactly what they need, but it is up to us to listen and be able to recognize that. Diseases require a little more attention and some even go undetected for years due to lack of symptoms. I am hesitant to believe that Ayurveda alone could “heal” any disease; diseases are just too strong. Take Diabetes as an example. I find it hard to believe that Ayurveda could essentially “heal” this disease. It is far too complex in how it operates and attacks the body.

Diabetes' connection to metabolic pathways is extremely interesting to me. When I was in high school I learned that my softball coach was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes at a very young age. He regularly had to keep track of his blood sugar, and we could always tell when it was getting low. Coach would get agitated and leave practice suddenly only to return about 15 minutes later with a juice box and a sucker. I never knew about the other side effects that come with it or really what was happening underneath the skin that caused Type 1 diabetes. I now understand that it has to do with the body's metabolic pathways and whether or not it is able to produce its own insulin. 

Beta cells are the cells that help to produce insulin, and diabetes stops that by damaging these beta cells and even sometimes causes beta cell death. One driver of type 2 diabetes is obesity. Obesity is one of the most prevalent diseases taking over America today, and it is shown statistically to be of greater effect with type 2 diabetes in some states rather than others. I found it particularly intriguing reading about the connection with mental health and diabetes in the article , Chronic Illness and Mental Health, published by the National Institute of Mental Health. I never thought about the connection between the two before, but I am always interested in anything having to do with mental health. It makes sense that individuals suffering from this disease will go through many ups and downs and that sort of instability can attend to a decrease in mental health. It may even be taken as far as to be a cause for depression which can often lead to suicidal tendencies. With mental illnesses, such as depression, many come with symptoms that further worsen the chronic illness that they already have. In the, Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2012, scientific statement article it was concluded that the economic burden of diabetes is only continuing to grow as years pass. According to the article, Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2017, from 2012 to 2017 the economic cost of diabetes increased by 26%. This was due to the increase in prevalence of diabetes and the increase of cost per person. This further supports that by being a victim to this awful disease one can become economically burdened. This, in turn, leads to worsening mental health. 





Works Cited

American Diabetes Association. “Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2017.”    Diabetes        Care, American Diabetes Association, 1 May 2018, care.diabetesjournals.org/content/41/5/917. 

American Diabetes Association. “Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2012.” Diabetes Care, vol. 36, no. 4, 2013, pp. 1033–1046., doi:10.2337/dc12-2625. 

“Chronic Illness & Mental Health.” National Institute of Mental Health, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/chronic-illness-mental-health-2015/index.shtml. 


3 comments:

  1. I was intrigued to hear your stance on the matter. For me, while I do agree that there are a number of issues within the old texts remedies and even current renditions of Ayurveda medicines. However, I don't think the base idea behind Ayurveda is that far off. Disease within the body typically comes about because of an imbalance in one of the many systems utilized by our bodies to keep them running. Additionally, if you look into what a lot of modern scientific articles are suggesting be done with Ayurveda, it focuses on trying to identify cheap, balanced drugs that will be able to treat symptoms without the issues of long lists of side-effects, as the plants themselves are able to incorporate complex mixtures of agonists and antagonists that we can only discover through costly experimentation. Finally, as for how something harmful being put into your body can be helpful, there are few medications that do not have the potential to be harmful in some way to our body, but we take them anyway. For most people, they do it without question, as they know the benefits out way the potential costs. It was very interesting to hear your perspective on it, and I appreciate being able to have a better understanding because of it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I definitely relate to your skepticism of Ayurveda, and while I think the practice on its own is probably not as effective as mainstream medicine, I agree the philosophy behind it is very relevant to managing health. I like the connection you drew between mental health and physical health with depression and diabetes. You mentioned that diabetes could be causing depression, and I agree that could be likely in many scenarios, but I think it could be the other way around in many cases. I wonder how often anxiety or depression could lead to unhealthy eating patterns that directly lead to obesity and, ultimately, to diabetes. You did mention that diabetes-caused depression could be affecting the condition that caused it, making it even worse, so I agree with you there. I would just take it a step further and investigate whether the mental illnesses were the ultimate cause instead of diabetes. It's like the chicken and the egg, huh?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yo Kinley I liked that while explaining all the things about Ayurveda you shared to details and also got into the nitty gritty of your thoughts and feelings about it while you took us through your examination of it. I share your skepticism of the Ayurvedic concoctions. Of course we sometimes take medication with undesirable side effects but that feels different to me than straight up ingesting lead. I also really appreciate you bringing mental health into the diabetes conversation, because I feel like that is an often-overlooked aspect of the conversation. Both that diabetes symptoms can increase depression and that depression can be pushing people off balance and worsening the factors that lead to diabetes. You were really saying lots of good things. You did strong work citing sources while you discussed diabetes, all I could suggest is that maybe your sections about Ayurveda could use some more credible citations, like telling us where you read about the harmful things in Ayurvedic products.

    ReplyDelete